Hurlbut Care nursing homes
Hurlbut Care is listed by CMS as the chain for 13 nursing homes in 1 state, with 1,037 certified beds in total. Their average CMS overall rating is 3.8 of 5 against a national average of 3.0, and 9 homes have 4 or 5 stars. CMS lists 6 fines totaling $1,065,045 across these homes in the past three years.
- Nursing homes
- 13
- States
- 1
- Average overall rating
- 3.8
- Fines, past three years
- $1,065,045
CMS groups homes into chains from ownership records. Totals and averages here are this site's sums of the homes listed below.
Across these homes
| Measure | Hurlbut Care | United States |
|---|---|---|
| Average overall rating (1 to 5) | 3.8 | 3.0 |
| Median nurse staffing hours per resident per day | 3.48 | 3.86 (average) |
| Average nursing staff turnover | 54.4% | 45.8% |
- Homes with 4 or 5 stars9 of 13
- Homes with a fine in the past three years4 of 13
- Homes in the CMS Special Focus program or candidates1
All 13 homes
New York
- 4 of 5 Avon Nursing Home L L C 40beds 93.8%in use 3.40nurse hours a day
- 1 of 5 Maple City Rehabilitation and Nursing Center 114beds 95.9%in use 3.01nurse hours a day
- 5 of 5 Conesus Lake Nursing Home, LLC 48beds 93.5%in use 3.11nurse hours a day
- 4 of 5 Newark Manor Nursing Home Inc 60beds 92.0%in use 3.60nurse hours a day
- 5 of 5 Penfield Place 48beds 93.8%in use 4.49nurse hours a day
- 4 of 5 Hamilton Manor Nursing Home 40beds 94.0%in use 3.38nurse hours a day
- 3 of 5 Latta Road Nursing Home East 40beds 92.2%in use 3.48nurse hours a day
- 5 of 5 Latta Road Nursing Home West 40beds 92.0%in use 3.51nurse hours a day
- 5 of 5 The Brightonian, Inc 54beds 91.9%in use 3.95nurse hours a day
- 2 of 5 The Hurlbut 160beds 77.6%in use 3.34nurse hours a day
- – not rated Waterview Heights Rehabilitation and Nursing Cente 229beds 82.9%in use 3.51nurse hours a day
- 4 of 5 Woodside Manor Nursing Home Inc 44beds 93.2%in use 3.88nurse hours a day
- 4 of 5 Seneca Nursing & Rehabilitation Center, LLC 120beds 56.2%in use 3.37nurse hours a day
The circle and stars show the CMS overall rating from 1 to 5. This is a list, not a ranking or a recommendation.
Common questions
How many nursing homes does Hurlbut Care operate?
CMS lists Hurlbut Care as the chain for 13 nursing homes in New York. CMS groups homes into chains from ownership records, so the list can differ from the company's own count.
How are Hurlbut Care nursing homes rated?
The average CMS overall rating of these homes is 3.8 of 5; the national average is 3.0. 9 of 13 have 4 or 5 stars.
Have Hurlbut Care nursing homes been fined?
Yes. CMS lists 6 fines totaling $1,065,045 in the past three years, at 4 of the 13 homes.
Source: CMS Provider Data Catalog, nursing home datasets processed Sep 1, 2026. All chains