Otterbein Seniorlife nursing homes
Otterbein Seniorlife is listed by CMS as the chain for 20 nursing homes in 2 states, with 1,344 certified beds in total. Their average CMS overall rating is 3.1 of 5 against a national average of 3.0, and 7 homes have 4 or 5 stars. CMS lists 9 fines totaling $176,234 across these homes in the past three years.
- Nursing homes
- 20
- States
- 2
- Average overall rating
- 3.1
- Fines, past three years
- $176,234
CMS groups homes into chains from ownership records. Totals and averages here are this site's sums of the homes listed below.
Across these homes
| Measure | Otterbein Seniorlife | United States |
|---|---|---|
| Average overall rating (1 to 5) | 3.1 | 3.0 |
| Median nurse staffing hours per resident per day | 4.09 | 3.86 (average) |
| Average nursing staff turnover | 49.4% | 45.8% |
- Homes with 4 or 5 stars7 of 20
- Homes with a fine in the past three years6 of 20
- Homes in the CMS Special Focus program or candidates0
All 20 homes
Indiana
Ohio
- 3 of 5 Otterbein Union Township 60beds 90.7%in use 4.27nurse hours a day
- 4 of 5 Otterbein Springboro 60beds 95.5%in use 4.44nurse hours a day
- 3 of 5 Otterbein-Cridersville 50beds 89.2%in use 3.74nurse hours a day
- 4 of 5 Otterbein Middletown 60beds 90.0%in use 4.19nurse hours a day
- 2 of 5 Otterbein Gahanna 60beds 93.3%in use 3.85nurse hours a day
- 5 of 5 Otterbein at Granville 22beds 93.6%in use 4.46nurse hours a day
- 5 of 5 Otterbein North Shore 20beds 95.5%in use 4.80nurse hours a day
- 5 of 5 Otterbein Lebanon Retirement Community 154beds 91.8%in use 4.00nurse hours a day
- 1 of 5 Otterbein Loveland 60beds 101.2%in use –nurse hours a day
- 3 of 5 Otterbein at Maineville 60beds 88.5%in use 4.49nurse hours a day
- 2 of 5 Otterbein Monclova 60beds 93.0%in use 4.30nurse hours a day
- 1 of 5 Otterbein New Albany 60beds 95.2%in use 4.56nurse hours a day
- 4 of 5 Otterbein Portage Valley 50beds 91.4%in use 3.46nurse hours a day
- 3 of 5 Avalon by Otterbein at Perrysburg 60beds 92.3%in use 4.73nurse hours a day
- 4 of 5 Otterbein St Marys Retirement Community 53beds 93.8%in use 3.49nurse hours a day
- 2 of 5 Otterbein Sunset Village 50beds 92.2%in use 3.71nurse hours a day
- 2 of 5 Springmeade Healthcenter 99beds 88.7%in use 3.36nurse hours a day
- 3 of 5 Otterbein Sunset House 24beds 87.9%in use 4.09nurse hours a day
- 3 of 5 Green Hills Center 74beds 98.1%in use 3.53nurse hours a day
The circle and stars show the CMS overall rating from 1 to 5. This is a list, not a ranking or a recommendation.
Common questions
How many nursing homes does Otterbein Seniorlife operate?
CMS lists Otterbein Seniorlife as the chain for 20 nursing homes in Indiana, Ohio. CMS groups homes into chains from ownership records, so the list can differ from the company's own count.
How are Otterbein Seniorlife nursing homes rated?
The average CMS overall rating of these homes is 3.1 of 5; the national average is 3.0. 7 of 20 have 4 or 5 stars.
Have Otterbein Seniorlife nursing homes been fined?
Yes. CMS lists 9 fines totaling $176,234 in the past three years, at 6 of the 20 homes.
Source: CMS Provider Data Catalog, nursing home datasets processed Sep 1, 2026. All chains