Power of Attorney vs Guardianship: Who Decides for Mom?
Esta guía también está en español.
Key takeaways
- A power of attorney is a legal document the person signs to give someone authority; guardianship is a state court process in which a judge finds the person incapacitated under state law and appoints someone to decide.
- Federal rules count an agent under a power of attorney, a representative payee, a person the resident chooses and a court-appointed guardian or conservator as possible resident representatives.
- A nursing home must treat a representative's decisions as the resident's only to the extent required by the court or delegated by the resident, and may not let the representative go beyond that.
- The resident keeps every right not delegated, and even with a court-appointed guardian, the resident's wishes must be considered and decisions outside a limited guardian's authority stay with the resident.
- A power of attorney alone does not let an agent manage Social Security benefits, and a certified home may not request or require a third-party guarantee of payment as a condition of admission or continued stay.
Short answer
A power of attorney is a legal document a person signs to give someone else authority, such as over money, property or health care decisions. Guardianship is a state court process: a judge finds a person incapacitated under state law and appoints someone to decide for them. In a nursing home, either one can make a family member a "resident representative," but only within the authority the document, state law or the court gives.
Being a relative is not the same as holding a power of attorney or guardianship, though some state laws name relatives as default health care decision makers.
What is the difference between power of attorney and guardianship?
The main difference is who gives the authority: with a power of attorney, the person does; with guardianship, a court does. The Administration for Community Living (ACL) describes powers of attorney and other formal supports as arrangements in which "an adult authorizes a person to perform a specific task on their behalf through the execution of a legal document," and guardianship (called conservatorship in some states) as a legal process in which a state court finds a person incapacitated under state law and appoints someone else to make decisions for them.
| Question | Power of attorney | Guardianship |
|---|---|---|
| Who sets it up? | The person, by signing a legal document | A state court, after finding the person incapacitated |
| What does it cover? | What the document says, such as money or health care | What state law and the court order allow |
| Can it be limited? | Yes, to the decisions named in the document | Yes. ACL says it can be "limited" or "full" |
| When does it end? | If revoked, or at death; it may end if a court names a guardian or conservator | When the court ends it, for example because the person died or no longer needs a guardian |
The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) says a court can name a guardian or conservator to manage a person's money and property if the court decides the person can't manage their money alone and has no power of attorney in place. A court can also split financial and health care decisions between different people. ACL says state laws generally allow guardianship only as a last resort.
Who counts as a "resident representative" in a nursing home?
Federal rules (42 CFR § 483.5) define a resident representative as any of these:
- a person the resident chooses to help with decisions, information, money matters or notifications;
- a person authorized by State or Federal law, including agents under a power of attorney, representative payees and other fiduciaries;
- a legal representative as used in section 712 of the Older Americans Act;
- a court-appointed guardian or conservator.
The same definition says nothing in it is meant to expand a representative's authority beyond what the resident, State or Federal law, or a court specifically authorized.
What must the nursing home do with a representative's decisions?
The home must treat a representative's decisions as the resident's own, but only as far as the court required or the resident delegated. Under 42 CFR § 483.10(b)(3)–(7):
- The resident can name a representative. A resident who has not been found incompetent by a state court "has the right to designate a representative, in accordance with State law."
- Only delegated rights pass. The resident keeps every right not delegated, including the right to revoke a delegation, except as limited by State law.
- The home follows decisions within that authority. The home "must treat the decisions of a resident representative as the decisions of the resident to the extent required by the court or delegated by the resident."
- The home may not go further. The home "shall not extend the resident representative the right to make decisions on behalf of the resident beyond" that extent.
- Concerns are reported. If the home has reason to believe a representative is not acting in the resident's best interests, it must report the concern in the manner State law requires.
- Court-appointed representatives. If a court has found the resident incompetent, the resident's rights pass to the representative appointed under State law, to the extent the court judged necessary.
Even with a court-appointed representative, if State law or the court limits the representative's authority, the resident keeps the right to make decisions outside it; the resident's wishes and preferences must be considered, and, to the extent practicable, the resident must get chances to take part in care planning. See care plan meeting questions and the full list of nursing home residents' rights.
What is a health care proxy or advance directive?
An advance directive is a written instruction about health care for a time when the person is incapacitated. Federal rules (42 CFR § 489.100) define it as "a written instruction, such as a living will or durable power of attorney for health care, recognized under State law." ACL describes these related tools:
- Health care power of attorney: the adult authorizes someone to make specified health care decisions, immediately or when the adult becomes unable to make them.
- Living will: a type of advance directive in which the adult says which treatments they do and do not want.
- Health care surrogate or proxy under state law: a default decision maker under state law, such as a spouse, parent, adult child or sibling, who can make health care decisions when the adult cannot make or communicate them.
The CFPB notes that a power of attorney for money and property is separate from a health care power of attorney.
What does the nursing home have to tell you about advance directives at admission?
A skilled nursing facility must give written information about advance directives at the time the person is admitted as a resident. Under 42 CFR § 483.10(g)(12) and § 489.102, the home must:
- tell adult residents in writing about the right to accept or refuse treatment and to make an advance directive, with its own policies and applicable State law;
- note in a prominent part of the medical record whether the person has an advance directive;
- not condition care, or otherwise discriminate, based on whether the person has one;
- tell people that complaints about these requirements may be filed with the State survey agency.
If the person is incapacitated at admission, the home may give this information to the resident representative under State law, and must still give it to the resident once they are able to receive it.
How does guardianship work for a nursing home resident?
Guardianship runs through a state court under state law, so the steps differ by state. The CFPB tells court-appointed guardians of property and conservators that their powers and duties are written in state law and may also be written in the court order, and that their powers may be limited.
One state's example (Alaska): the Alaska Court System's self-help pages describe guardianship as an arrangement in which "the court appoints a person(s) to make decisions for an incapacitated individual about housing, medical care, legal issues, and services." Alaska's pages say the court will schedule a hearing on incapacity within 120 days after the petition is filed, unless it finds a good reason to delay. Other states use other forms and timelines.
What about Social Security checks and the admission contract?
A power of attorney alone does not let an agent manage Social Security payments. The CFPB says an agent cannot manage Social Security or VA benefits without a separate appointment from that agency, such as a representative payee or VA fiduciary. ACL says the Social Security Administration appoints a representative payee to receive Social Security or SSI benefits on the adult's behalf. See can a nursing home take your Social Security.
A certified home cannot make a promise to pay from your own money a condition of admission. Under 42 CFR § 483.15(a)(3), a certified home must not request or require a third-party guarantee of payment as a condition of admission or continued stay. The home may ask a representative with legal access to the resident's income or resources to sign a contract to pay from those funds, without incurring personal financial liability. See signing as the responsible party.
Where can families get official forms and help?
Forms and help come from state courts and public programs.
- Your state court system handles guardianship and conservatorship cases. Alaska's self-help pages, for example, list forms, filing information and an adult guardianship self-help phone line.
- Eldercare Locator, 1-800-677-1116, is a public service of ACL that connects older adults and families with services.
- Long-Term Care Ombudsman. The ombudsman program handles complaints made by or on behalf of nursing home residents.
- CFPB "Managing someone else's money" guides explain the duties of agents, guardians, conservators and government fiduciaries. The CFPB says they are not legal advice.
To look up a home, search by name, city or ZIP code. To file a concern, see how to file a nursing home complaint.